Pot Depth—Don’t Cut it Close!

The guideline runs: pot depth should equal trunk diameter. This, though, is an aesthetic guideline. Many bonsai prefer a deeper pot. 

A deep pot is like sneakers. Good for romping around in. The high heels and dress shoes are for primp, kept in the closet with the shallow show pots for special days.

There are species preferences in pot depth, shared in the following photos-

108B9254-1A4B-4D04-B427-C0A75E7D054D

This Japanese White Pine bunjin is mounded. This adds additional depth to a pot already twice as deep as the thickest trunk. Pines are happiest in deeper pots. (Photo courtesy Bonsai Empire.)

EEFC8E90-D80A-4D31-904E-CFC113D307CF

Shore Pine with a trunk girth half the depth of the pot—a good year-round growing pot.

54149E4C-708D-4B1E-927B-DF43675CD09A

The guideline works better with maples. The pot is as deep as the thickest trunk—a great show pot, and with care can function as a year-round pot. Slightly upsizing this pot would allow greater ease of care and plant vigor.

B8CB9B51-B153-44D4-B415-5A0483F1B597

A Japanese Maple ‘Beni-kawa’ in a shallow pot. (This is an oval pot, photographed from the side.) Maples grow well in shallow pots year-round.

33FA8D6E-E9EB-4C7C-B9D2-D88C5E7F81A3

Shrubs are another matter. They do better in deeper pots. I don’t recommend growing Chojubai or Azaleas in shallow pots. Most of my Chojubai are in much deeper pots than this one. This one only works horticulturally as a year-round pot because the soil is mounded.

14A76A03-3328-46FF-9504-23DFB639BCD6

Another Chojubai. Deeper pots offer easier year-round shrub care.

9970B1D1-E8C7-490D-B9B8-806D7D414FC7

Skinny-trunked azalea in a deep pot. (Photo courtesy Andrew Robson.)

Carmen, my current apprentice, demonstrating proper wand technique. (Actually what I want you to notice is this Azalea’s largest trunk is about half the diameter of the pot depth. A good year-round growing pot.)

F3895B3E-D114-4299-B297-B9D7CC02992C

John Eads, past apprentice, with Carmen, both clearly excited by this azalea trunk’s girth being half the depth of the pot (even though flowers are hiding it).

EF83CED8-EFA1-4766-8003-831CB5327448

Once you reach this girth, the pot depth can be similar to trunk girth and all is well in shrub land. Deep pots offer better drainage to a greater percentage of the soil mass.

468E7E98-B9CD-45B9-81F2-0DEB3DC404A8

A favorite photo of my teacher, Mr. Shinji Suzuki. This photo is from ages ago. Maybe 2004. He’s sitting next to a Cotoneaster in a pot twice as deep as the trunk girth. A good pot to grow in year-round. 

5 Comments

  1. Ray says:

    Great advice Michael. Thanks for this post
    Ray

  2. David M. Schleser says:

    But wouldn’t where you live make a difference? Here in Dallas TX, according to Kathy Shaner, maples need deeper pots than in the Pacific Northwest.

    • crataegus says:

      Yes absolutely. Everything I state on the blog is relative and should be modified (and maybe even taken with a grain of salt) according to where you live. Thanks for the note!

  3. Bill Wall says:

    Thank you
    For all of your time and experience you share

  4. Dave Leppo says:

    “Deep pots offer better drainage to a greater percentage of the soil mass.” This is counter intuitive, but I can imagine it has to do with gravity pulling the water through the substrate, and the taller the water column, the more force pulls it through.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: