Are We Missing Something?

A comment from last week’s post on Chojubai by Mr. Grahn had me thinking about connoisseurship. A connoisseur, as a rough definition, is someone with much knowledge of arts or food, and is a particularly good judge of aesthetics and taste. A sort of art critic, you might say. The very people who end up ‘discovering’ something and, because they have loud voices, everyone looks over to see what they’re pointing at.

The quintessential connoisseur...a kind of art snob that you'd probably hesitate to invite to dinner, but who tends to be insightful.

For bonsai, this discovery or insight would be an over-looked plant for bonsai. I think relatively unknown plants sit at the periphery of the mainstream species until proven. Tradition is a wary animal. It wants it’s own proofs, like the essential repeatable experiments of science. For bonsai, those proofs would be:

– non-flashy aesthetic

– easily cultivated in a pot

– responsive to technique

– long-lived

– at least one season where it shines, even if during the others it looks horrible

– and a lot of people (connoisseurs) agreeing on those points (this is a tradition after all, not a one-man show)

Let’s take the example of Chojubai quince, from last week’s post. In the third paragraph of that post there was a historical note indicating how it’s popularity grew over some decades. I think that the great popularity that this plant now enjoys in Japan is two-fold: One, it meets all the criteria above. Second, it mirrors a rare aesthetic really only represented by one other plant: Ume, Japanese flowering apricot. Both are plants of unique contrasts, having roughened, craggy bark and trunk, yet producing the most delicate, simple flowers at a time of year when all else looks dead: Winter. Connoisseurship—the recognition of rare qualities—in Chojubai has prompted its rise to ‘appreciated plant’ status. All bow…

Well, I have my own reasons for being in love with Chojubai, and grow it avidly. But I suggest taking a good look at something you like—an under-appreciated plant, perhaps a native—and really push its possibilities. Take it to absurdity. And then see if you can convince your bonsai friends of its validity as a front-ranker!

If you become a connoisseur of something, it changes everything. It changes how the plant looks, because now you’re really attending to it, focusing attention and technique on it. And, just maybe, you might even change our communal perception of beauty.


  1. Great Post! I believe we will see several more N. American Native varieties of trees being widely used and accepted. I’m currently growing-Acer Glabrum, Prunus Ilicifolia and Prunus Subcordata or American Mountain Maple, Holly leaf Cherry and Sierra Plum from Seed and airlayers. We shall see if any of these meet your proofs over the long term. Thank you for the write up!

  1. […] the original: Are We Missing Something? « Crataegus Bonsai comments: Closed tags: bonsai, discovery, discovery-or-insight, mainstream, own-proofs, […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: